Ok I know the VS posts are an invitation to start flame wars and I really don’t like the idea of that but to be honest I think allot of good insight can be gained by a good flamewar so why the hell not. That being said I recently signed up for both a Slicehost VPS and a Media Temple GS account and I’d like to share my thoughts on both. They both start at 20$ a month and both allow you to scale nicely (albeit in slightly different ways) so I think it’s an obvious comparison, and honestly I would have loved to read about this when I was initially looking. PS I’m purposely going to steer clear of the grid vs vps scaling methodologies. You can read plenty about the merits of each approach on the respective sites.
Media Temple GS:
I started out first with the Media Temp account. I must admit the idea behind the Grid Server is very enticing. And to be honest Media Temple is very good at marketing. They have allot of buzz(not all good) and I figured hell why not. I had read all the initial reports about the issues with the grid hosting but I wasn’t really bothered by it. Besides it was quite a few months since they launched the product line and to be honest anyone who buys into something that is brand new and expects it to be bug free is smoking grade A jub rocks. For instance look at any Apple product… their great but only after they have been out for awhile and all the bullshit has been worked out.
So I decided to give them a shot. Hell its only 20$ a month. Not much to loose really. The setup was simple. They have a stupid easy admin interface. I also like the 1 click installers. This blog is running off of a one click install of Wordpress. The account also comes with email support. Cool… if there is one this I HATE its trying to setup and deal with my own email servers. It’s a serious pain and I was glad that they had that covered for me. So far so good…
Now on to the stuff I’m not thrilled about…
First… the server is fairly slow. I’ve talked to them a few times about this and they have even comp’d me a free month. It’s bearable and for a 20$ a month shared host it’s not surprising but with all the hype I would think that it would be faster.
Second… they give you very little access. I’m really used to having root. Call me crazy but I like to be in control. At work I have my own rack in colo so not having root is a kick in the nutz. I basically have to play nice with their control panel to do the majority of my configuration. Now I can do that and most likely thats fine for allot of the people who subscribe to this service but its kinda a buzzkill. Any of you sudo junkies out there know what I mean….
Third… every site is lumped under the parent site. Now don’t get me wronge I’m happy that you can host a bunch of vhosts under one account but I don’t really like that fact that in the control panel everything is nested under the main site. It makes me feel bad for my other sites. Like they are the red headed step children or something. I don’t know. I’m picky I guess. If you have a gs account you know what I mean. If you don’t well trust me is annoying.
Fourth… I CANT RUN DJANGO(yet). Ok I know this is changing but it’s taking FAR too long… that sux. Nuff said.
Slice Host VPS:
First off I love that they offer Ubuntu. I use that on all my work servers and I think it’s an awesome flavor. I also love that they give you a bucket full of tasty root access. WOOT I GOT ROOT! The server is fast too. Like really fast. That shit they say about not overselling their machines… well they must not be bullshitting because I have the dinky 256 slice and it’s blazing. So with root comes the power to install whatever. This pleases me to no end. I can finally run django.
Potential Drawbacks: (for some people)
First… no real control panel. Well they have something that lets you control your vps but as for setting up sites and databases etc your out of luck. I don’t use GUI control panels anyway so this is fine with me but I can see it would be a turn off to some people.
Second… no pre-configured email setup. Now no one is saying you can’t setup your own but there is nothing there out of the box.
Third… no one click install apps. I only mention this as it’s something I liked about my media temple account.
To sum it all up…
I think both product lines have their merits. For a beginner/hobbyist or someone who would rather concentrate of making your site then setting up your server I think Media Temple GS is an excellent choice. For someone who is already versed in server administration and doesn’t mind getting down and dirt with some server config I think slicehost is an excellent option.
As for me I’ll prob keep both. I like having my blogs on a server that I don’t really have to think about but the lack of speed and access kills me when it comes to development. So for my projects slicehost will get my money.
Just my 2 cents… Flame on flamers 